Complaints database
29,255 raw documents, unedited and searchable. This is what everything else on the site is built from — nothing here is generated.
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
The problem is 1. that artificial neurons are very restrictive model for actual neurons, let alone brain/organism, as there is more going on in neurons than a thresholded 0-1 activation 2. a brain does not function in isolation, but as regulator of the bodily functions (along with even more things). If you look a…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
Your “and then” is doing a lot of work there. The steps between may or may not include some form of “learn to understand humans”, but you can’t just hide them behind “and then” if what we are doing is claiming some particular thing is not in the list. Through training on human text, we are building implicitly in the w…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
Most spreadsheet engines are turing complete, so you could use them to run an LLM. I don't think many people would say an LLM written in Python is conscious BUT an LLM written in Excel is not. People just don't ascribe consciousness to things that can't converse (or at least emote or give the appearance of emoting), a…
Learn SQL Once, Use It for 30 Years
> If you are a junior developer, “learn SQL properly” is the most valuable 40 hours you can spend. Not a tutorial. Not an ORM. Actual SQL: joins, subqueries, window functions, query plans. That investment pays you back at every job, in every stack, for decades This is the power of low-level reasoning. Today, even for…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious
The false conclusion that's being drawn is "therefore LLMs could not be good models of consciousness" (consciousness being a cognitive capacity). Plus, I suppose a subtle implication that a good model of consciousness is not actually conscious. To which I would invoke the spirit of the Turing test: if you can't tell t…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
What does “understand” mean? Turing complete systems can be built out of matrix multiplications, out of attention, out of key/value lookups. The Chinese room is Turing complete. By claiming it cannot understand things because it is built out of components computing devices can be built out of, we are claiming no…
Dumbphone 2
Depends on your bank. A lot of banks in Germany still offer photoTAN generators. Effectively, a physical device that generates 2FA codes for your login. You can then use the website as usual and use the codes from this instead of phone confirmation. This is one example from ING.[0] That way you can effectively use mos…
They’re made out of weights
After reading Being and Time from Martin Heidegger, What Computers can't still do by Hubert Dreyfus, and some authors in cognitive linguistics (Langacker and Lakoff mainly), I strongly tend to disagree with any theory about emergent consciousness in modern or future AI systems, any theory proposing a similarity betwee…
Learn SQL Once, Use It for 30 Years
> Not a tutorial. Not an ORM. Actual SQL: joins, subqueries, window functions, query plans. My brain absolutely checks out when I read this stuff now. Not to mention that query plans are absolutely not "actual SQL".
American capitalism has taken an apocalyptic turn
> That's called "theft". In a free market, transactions are mutually agreed upon. Equal wealth for equal wealth. It's also called a Transaction with asymmetric information, or being in a position in an economic system where you cannot accumulate assets because the system is stacked against you. I also think you're con…
Dumbphone 2
I bought a cheap Android "dumbphone" specifically for going to the gym. I was constantly getting distracted responding to messages / browsing the internet while working out, so on this phone I only have my workout tracker and Spotify installed. I disabled the Chrome browser though an app restriction tool. The pho…
Learn SQL Once, Use It for 30 Years
> JavaScript is an imperative language that browser wars, framework trends, and open-source maintainer preferences reshaped every few years. It rewards you for keeping up. > Take a React component from 2015 Javascript is actually fully backwards-compatible, to not break the Web. Any javascript from 10 years ago works…
They’re made out of weights
> The point of the original short story is that the computational substrate doesn't matter when you have Turing completeness. That is your takeaway from the 1991 story?
American capitalism has taken an apocalyptic turn
Let me more specific. I am talking about wealth that is generated by capturing value from existing assets, transactions, and people rather than by producing new goods, services, or productivity gains. Examples are rent-seeking (making money through ownership, monopoly power, licensing, etc), financial extraction (fina…
Elixir v1.20: Now a gradually typed language
I use rails because it makes thousands of good choices that I never have to make. If build apps the rails way I don't have to deal with a mountain of tech debt (in the form bad or ever changing choices).
American capitalism has taken an apocalyptic turn
> When your part in wealth creation is having your wealth acquired by somebody else. That's called "theft". In a free market, transactions are mutually agreed upon. Equal wealth for equal wealth. > Wealth creation only works when the the money available to buy wealth creating instruments is significantly less than the…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
> Second, there is no reason to suppose that Claude experiencing those qualia I'd argue the qualia question is a red herring. Functional Affect is a thing, regardless of ontological status. It's all fun and games until someone gets hurt. To paraphrase Dijkstra: "The question of whether a computer can think is no more…
Mathematicians issue warning as AI rapidly gains ground
> Think of it as 1000+ ways to think of that word/token I assume you used 1000 because that's in the ballpark of the vector size. But these are not independent scalars, like each might store a certain property. Just like in 2D you can have 4 quadrants (or subdivide further), with a vector of size 1000 you can enc…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
I think Turing was wrong because he was uncomfortable with ambiguity, and the Turing Test basically is a way to avoid philosophical argument, but it is ultimately a philosophical argument anyway. Plenty of computer scientists have followed in Turing's footsteps, terrified of ambiguity, relying on a kind of cheap funct…
Embryos shape their limbs: a key discovery of "genetic brakes"
They've found some real chemical P and S for the turing patterns
They’re made out of weights
It's not often I see something that's fractally wrong but here we are. There is a dictionary, it's called the tokenizer. There are grammar rules, they are just very weak because the structure of human language is generally quite weak. When presented with languages which have strong consistent grammars the weights are…
Elixir v1.20: Now a gradually typed language
Rails is still fantastic and handles massive load. 15 percent of all US commerce uses Ruby on Rails
Elixir v1.20: Now a gradually typed language
I’ve been using Ruby and Elixir for over a decade. Pre-AI I used them for aesthetic reasons. The code was beautiful, and I disliked dealing with types. People without experience in dynamic languages tend to overestimate the number of bugs their type system is saving them from. It’s pretty rare that I run into a bug in…
Uber's $1,500/month AI limit is a useful signal for AI tool pricing
I’ve even heard the rule “twice the salary” being used here in EU, but the tax and insurance burden may be higher. All kinds of those are based primarily on total payroll amount.
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
What is the argument behind the Turing test?
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
The Turing Test measures human gullibility, not machine intelligence.
China vs. Taiwan: The Geography of an Unfinished War
A more accurate formulation would be their strategy for decades has been asserting commercial influence on their political opponents. Going back further, this chimes with their overall strategy. From the center, expand out. Hard when safest, but soft and covert when more effective. Always a form of aggression. South C…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
It's becoming painfully evident that no one really understood the argument behind the Turing test.
MacBook Neo is so popular that Apple doubled production
They're fine if you just need it mainly for the build/bundle step. I've used an 8GB M1 mac for react-native iOS dev for over a year back when the M1 first came out. If I had to look for the cheapest way to build iOS apps, but still on a laptop form factor (aka no mac minis), and I don't use macOS for day-to-day d…
Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
The Turing test comes to mind. It no longer being the gold standard for thinking machines.